- Title
- Investigating the correlation between pre- and post-demolition assessments for precast, post-tensioned beams in service for 45 years
- Creator
- Pape, Torill
- Relation
- University of Newcastle Research Higher Degree Thesis
- Resource Type
- thesis
- Date
- 2008
- Description
- Research Doctorate - Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
- Description
- The Sorell Causeway Bridge, located in Tasmania, Australia, was completed in 1957 and was the first precast, post-tensioned bridge constructed in Australia. However after only 45 years of service, the bridge was replaced due to increasing concerns surrounding the level of corrosion of the prestressing strands in the beams. Prior to its decommission, an extensive and costly investigation program was carried out on the bridge in an attempt to determine the rate of deterioration and establish the remaining margin of safety. Despite the number of investigations and the resulting large quantities of information, the questions surrounding the safety of the bridge remained unanswered. The issue is thus raised: what do field investigations of reinforced or prestressed concrete structures with evidence of corrosion deterioration tell engineers about the actual condition of the structure? Three beams of varying condition (good, average, poor) were salvaged from the bridge demolition for further detailed examination to investigate the degree of correlation between pre-demolition field investigations and the physical condition of the steel post-demolition. The investigations included the use of conventional non-destructive techniques such as cover, half-cell potential and concrete resistivity surveys, and destructive techniques such as chloride profiling, carbonation depth measurement, and full-scale load testing, all of which were used to determine the likely risk of corrosion and likely corrosion rate for each beam. The results of these investigations were subsequently reviewed in relation to the physical condition of the steel. In general, all non-destructive tests were found to be inconclusive in relation to evidence of steel corrosion and the corrosion risk guidelines recommended in the literature. It was also apparent that these techniques were incapable of detecting steel pitting, a primary concern for the current investigation. Chloride profiles were variable and inconsistent in relation to steel corrosion and the chloride thresholds recommended in the literature. Carbonation was found to exist at prestressing levels in some locations and appeared to be influenced by the orientation and geometry of the beams. All beams did not achieve the estimated design capacity and corrosion had significantly impaired the ultimate capacity and ductility of beams in the worst condition. Aerobic and anaerobic corrosion products were identified via XRD analysis. These included Magnetite, Goethite, Akaganeite, Lepidocrocite, chloride based Green Rust (I), and Iron (III) Oxide Chloride. The phenomenon of “chloride weeping”, or droplets of highly acidic ferrous chloride, was observed forming on some steel/concrete interfaces on freshly cut concrete surfaces. Several other unexplainable observations were made during the course of the present investigations. These included bright, metallic pit surfaces; pits with concentric rings; black, wet rust covering bright, metallic surfaces; and unusual pitting profiles. A possible explanation for these observations may be the implication of microbiological activity in the corrosion process. Further research is required to confirm these observations.
- Subject
- prestressed concrete; field investigations; flexural capacity; corrosion products; pitting; iron chlorides; microbiological activity; corrosion; non destructive testing; concrete cover; half-cell potential; concrete resistivity; carbonation; chloride profiles; load test
- Identifier
- http://hdl.handle.net/1959.13/807506
- Identifier
- uon:7426
- Rights
- Copyright 2008 Torill Pape
- Language
- eng
- Full Text
- Hits: 1751
- Visitors: 2913
- Downloads: 711
| Thumbnail | File | Description | Size | Format | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| View Details Download | ATTACHMENT01 | Abstract | 394 KB | Adobe Acrobat PDF | View Details Download | ||
| View Details Download | ATTACHMENT02 | Thesis | 13 MB | Adobe Acrobat PDF | View Details Download |