Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/1959.13/40491

OpenURL Link
Title
How should we use information about HWE in the meta-analyses of genetic association studies?
Author/Creator
Minelli, Cosetta;  Thompson, John R.;  Abrams, Keith R.;  Thakkinstian, Ammarin;  Attia, John
Institution
The University of Newcastle. Faculty of Health, School of Medicine and Public Health
Description
Background: It is often recommended that control groups in meta-analyses of genetic association studies are checked for Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) as a surrogate for assessing study quality. However, tests for HWE have low power and there is currently no consensus about how to handle studies that deviate significantly from HWE. Methods: We identified 72 papers describing 114 meta-analyses of 1603 primary gene–disease comparisons. Based on these studies andon related simulations, we evaluated four different strategies for handling studies that appear not to be in HWE: (i) include them in the meta-analysis; (ii) exclude them if the test for HWE results in P<0.05; (iii) exclude them if a measure of the size of departure from HWE is large and (iv) exclude them if (ii) and (iii). Results: Of the 72 papers, 26 did not report information on HWE, with a trend toward increased reporting with time. HWE was evaluated through testing, with only three papers assessing the size of departure. On re-analysis, 9% of the 1603 primary comparisons showed significant deviation from HWE. The chance of an extreme departure from HWE was inversely related to the sample size of the study. Simulations suggest that there is no advantage in excluding studies that appear not to be in HWE. Conclusions: Meta-analyses should report both the magnitude and the statistical significance of departures from HWE. Studies that appear to deviate from HWE should be investigated further for weaknesses in theirdesign, but these studies should not be excluded unless there are other grounds for doubting the quality of the study.
Relation
International Journal of Epidemiology Vol. 37, Issue 1, p. 136-146
Publisher Link
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ije/dym234
Date
2008
Publisher
Oxford University Press
Keyword(s)
Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium;  genetic association studies;  meta-analysis;  population stratification;  genotype distributions
Resource Type
journal article
Identifier
http://hdl.handle.net/1959.13/40491
Identifier
ISSN:0300-5771
Reviewed
Reviewed
48 Visitors 51 Hits 0 Downloads
Save/E-mail Citation
Citation Format
E-mail Address
Subject
"International Journal of Epidemiology"
 
OR