Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/1959.13/929542

OpenURL Link
Title
Healing, efficacy and the spirits
Author/Creator
Samuel, Geoffrey
Institution
The University of Newcastle. Faculty of Education & Arts, School of Humanities and Social Science
Description
Modes of explanation and treatment for ill-health based on ideas about spirit attack or other non-material causes exist in many societies, usually alongside forms of explanation and treatment which appear more 'rational' by Western biomedical standards. The separation between mind and body, and between self and other, in Western thought present obstacles to understanding such modes of treatment. They lead anthropologists and others to sec spirit healing and similar techniques as concerned with 'subjective' aspects of ill-health (illness rather than disease, in Kleinman's well-known formulation) and to focus explanatory and analytical models on social aspects of the healing process. The body can only be integrated into such analyses through assumptions of 'somatization; the 'placebo effect; etc., but these are of only limited use in understanding how spirit healing might affect bodily processes. I argue that we can go further, but only if we take the spirit-language more seriously; not in terms of occult forces, but as providing tokens and images for operating on the structure of human life at all levels, within a framework which does not assume rigid distinctions between mind and body, or self and other. An initial approach derives from taking spirits as representative of particular modes of action and feeling. This enables us to see the language of the spirits as a way to rebalance organismic functioning in relation to various kinds of physiological stress, a rebalancing which may be seen as contributing directly to organismic healing at a physiological (material) level, rather than operating in purely 'psychological' terms.
Relation
Journal of Ritual Studies Vol. 24, Issue 2
Relation
http://www.pitt.edu/~strather/journal.htm
Date
2010
Publisher
University of Pittsburgh
Keyword(s)
healing;  occult forces;  biomedicine;  anthropology
Resource Type
journal article
Identifier
http://hdl.handle.net/1959.13/929542
Identifier
ISSN:0890-1112
Reviewed
Reviewed
11 Visitors 21 Hits 0 Downloads
Save/E-mail Citation
Citation Format
E-mail Address
Subject
"Journal of Ritual Studies"
 
OR